Heckler

[daloonieshaman]

I think I'd rule that negatrait are not cancelled (including Stunty and Titchy drawback) but the benefit of any skill is ignored (including the benefit of Stunty and Titchy) that makes it fairly easy to rule, and makes the card quiet good...

can't have one without the other
you cancel a skill it cancels the WHOLE skill

[Greyhound]

I was making a clean cut at making it simple (remove whatever is good)
If you want to house rule a list of skills the heckler removes GFI. Would you consider Stunty as a skill the heckler leaves or cancels?

[Grumbledook]

I would just blanket remove every skill apart from frenzy (or remove the card), otherwise it would be a case by case basis

take the good with the bad, the player is being heckled, there is enough there to see removal of the negative traits imo

induced blood lust towards the heckler ;]

[Ironjaw]

Just use common sense FFS- How the hell can something forget to regenerate?

[dode74]

Just use common sense FFS- How the hell can something forget to regenerate?

Because it's dead

[Ullis]

I would just blanket remove every skill apart from frenzy (or remove the card), otherwise it would be a case by case basis

take the good with the bad, the player is being heckled, there is enough there to see removal of the negative traits imo

I think this is a sensible approach. If you can't work your head around it then bear in mind that it's magical heckling.

[duckwing]

Of course, then you wouldn't be following the text on the cards, which gives the examples "frenzy, loner etc." as skills that must be used. So besides frenzy you need to leave loner and at least one other skill.

[Heff]

Given my history with rules I am going to be careful here.
Also I have never used a player with regen

BUT

Clearly regen can be used as it works even if you are dead! and you don't get more distracted than that.

If you countered that
"Heckler won't work on a dead player but an injured one can hear him so it will"

You will have run foul of Heffs 11th commandment

"Never play a rules lawyer"

I would smile sweetly let you do it and never play you again