Talk Fantasy Football

This is likely listed/discussed somewhere, but I was unable to find it in the LRB5, and my search fu appears to be weak.

This came up in a game last night, and we were unable to find anything definitive, so we punted, as it were.

Player B is the ball carrier.
Player A (opposing team) blocks player B and scores a POW!, knocking B back and down.
The ball drops from player B's final position.
Does Player A have to decide whether to follow-up, moving into player Bs vacated space BEFORE the bounce direction is determined, or can he wait until after before deciding?

Thanks!

If he wants to Follow Up, he must decide before the bounce.

Of course, if it's a Blitz, he can decide not to Follow Up, see where the ball bounces, then move into that square at the cost of 1 MA.

Thanks Darkson!

Very helpful to know. :) Especially since we ended up doing it right. :)

John

lerchey wrote:This is likely listed/discussed somewhere, but I was unable to find it in the LRB5, and my search fu appears to be weak.

This came up in a game last night, and we were unable to find anything definitive, so we punted, as it were.

Player B is the ball carrier.
Player A (opposing team) blocks player B and scores a POW!, knocking B back and down.
The ball drops from player B's final position.
Does Player A have to decide whether to follow-up, moving into player Bs vacated space BEFORE the bounce direction is determined, or can he wait until after before deciding?

Thanks!

The right sequence is
1. Block
2. Choose destination of knocked down player (if "Defender Down" or "Defender Stumbles" caused the Knock down
3. Choose if you want to follow up or not
4. Roll for armor and casuality
5. Bounce the ball

This is sequence is IMPORTANT. You have to roll armor and eventually remove ko or casuality before bouncing... because the ball can bounce on you, you can fail the catch, and bounce again the the defender square. If the defender is KO or Injuried, the ball wil rest... but if the defender is simply prone or stunned the ball will bounce once more

Please note that the BBRC do not agree on the sequence of 4 & 5 on that list. So until we agree and then clarify it play which ever way your league prefers.

EDIT - Saw the comment in the other thread after posting this. We will discuss whether we need to clarify since someone always played the other way! <surprise! we are all human, no really, even Jervis>

ianwilliams wrote:Please note that the BBRC do not agree on the sequence of 4 & 5 on that list. So until we agree and then clarify it play which ever way your league prefers.

Page 7 of the LRB 5.0 state it very clear

"Make armour and injury rolls for players that were knocked down, and if the ball was dropped then roll to see where it bounces too normally"

Now, if you roll for bounch before armor/injury, you're not playing following the LRB 5.0
Nothing wrong with it, but it's important that all the league member know before starting that your league is using an house rule

And the description of the injuries clearly state that the players are removed:
8-9 KO’d – Take the player off the pitch and place them in the Dugout in the KO’d Players box.
10-12 Casualty – Take the player off the pitch and place them in the Dugout in the Dead & Injured Players box.
So in order to properly finish "roll for injury" you also have to take the players off the pitch on KO and CAS.
So I don't see how Galak can think otherwise

Interesting. I hadn't read that the players were removed instantly. We have KO and Casualty markers that we place on the field. Maybe we don't need those any more...

:)

but to leave the players on field until the next kickoff may be a good houserule.

after all, who would push himself into a bunch of brawling thugs to retrieve something that looks like a dead body from the distance?

If you go that route, I'd suggest some kind of body counter, so there isn't any confusion as to who is ko'd or cas'd as opposed to just stunned.

Daefaroth wrote:If you go that route, I'd suggest some kind of body counter, so there isn't any confusion as to who is ko'd or cas'd as opposed to just stunned.

'f course there will be.