Talk Fantasy Football

Question about adding MA, ST, AG or AV to a player.

The rule is +2 max, and injuries can allow something to go down to minimum of 1. So can someone give us the correct answers for the two scenarios below, even if highly unlikely.

QUESTION 1: So lets say I have a player that gets MA+1, MA+1 and Block, as his first 3 skill rolls. Then the player receives a MA-1, MA-1, for injuries. His next skill roll is 10, so another MA+1, AV+1 or Skill, can the player get the the MA+1 or does he have to take a skill due to him already having a MA+2 over his career?

QUESTION 2: Same scenario different stat. So lets say I have a player with 2 AG, that gets AG+1, AG+1 and Block, as his first 3 skill rolls. Then that player receives a string of bad injuries AG-1, AG-1, AG-1, AG-1 and AG-1 for injuries. Now his AG is 1 because that the minimum it can go. His next skill roll is 11, so another AG+1, can the player get the the AG+1 or does he have to take a skill due to him already having a AG+2 over his career or is his AG now a 2 due to the order of the injuries and skills?

Thanks!

fatfinley wrote: QUESTION 1: So lets say I have a player that gets MA+1, MA+1 and Block, as his first 3 skill rolls. Then the player receives a MA-1, MA-1, for injuries. His next skill roll is 10, so another MA+1, AV+1 or Skill, can the player get the the MA+1 or does he have to take a skill due to him already having a MA+2 over his career?

You can take the +MA, however you will now be paying 90k on the player cost for only one stat increase

fatfinley wrote:QUESTION 2: Same scenario different stat. So lets say I have a player with 2 AG, that gets AG+1, AG+1 and Block, as his first 3 skill rolls. Then that player receives a string of bad injuries AG-1, AG-1, AG-1, AG-1 and AG-1 for injuries. Now his AG is 1 because that the minimum it can go. His next skill roll is 11, so another AG+1, can the player get the the AG+1 or does he have to take a skill due to him already having a AG+2 over his career or is his AG now a 2 due to the order of the injuries and skills?

As per the Casualty Table:
-1 MA, ST, AG, and AV: Miss next game as above. In addition, record
the characteristic change on the team roster. However, no
characteristic may be reduced by more than 2 points or below a
value of 1. Any injuries that could reduce it further are ignored.

So the 5th -AG is ignored (though he would still miss a game) and can can take an AG+ again.
Though, again, why would you

No reason to take any of them, I agree. But this was brought up at league night and we all had different ideas as to what happens in those unlikely scenarios.

Thanks for the answer.

fatfinley wrote:No reason to take any of them, I agree. But this was brought up at league night and we all had different ideas as to what happens in those unlikely scenarios.

Thanks for the answer.

My group have had the exact same discussion

You have too much time on your hands no spent playing or painting!