Reaper Frankenstein's Monster vs. GW Flesh Golems - Scale?

[Genghis]

Anyone has a GW Flesh Golem (new or old) and the Reaper Frankenstein's Monster mini pictured below? How well do they match up in terms of scale?

[Da Crusha]

this guy is bigger. what I did was take a pic of this guy mounted on a 25mm round base and got a pic of the flesh golem on a 25mm base from gw and put them on the same page on paintbrush. then just shrink one pic until the bases are the same size. the size difference will become obvious.

[Genghis]

Thanks. I just tried your method, and he does look much bigger than the old 2ed Frank 'n Stein.

However, he does seem to be comparable to the newer "5th" edition model in scale, but I'd like to see if I can find someone with both for an actual comparison. I'm not sure if the angles are off on the pictures I'm looking at.

My best bet might be the Heresy golem. He's the right height, but looks a little scrawny compared to the Reaper one.

[Norse]

reaper mini is on a 25mm base and looks great for a St4 dude...

the only issue will be cutting off the integrated base..

I always hated the way Reaper did those models attached to their bases...

[bound for glory]

the B7 frank is quite nice(if you can find one).

[Lard]

B7 frank is here: http://www.neomics.de/shop/b7/b7-flesh-golem-2011